Oster 5838 58-Minute Expressbake Breadmaker Reviews

Oster 5838 58-Minute Expressbake Breadmaker Reviews

07The Oster 5838 58-minute Expressbake Breadmaker is a great concept, but suffers from a few flaws that may not make it the best investment. The machine is capable of producing two pound loaves in under an hour, which is quite impressive. Other positive features include the price point, and the horizontal loaf pan. As you will see in this review, however, the horizontal loaf pan may be the origin of the machine’s primary flaws.

Key features

  • Bakes up to a 2 lb loaf in less than 1 hour
  • Inexpensive
  • 13 hour timer delay
  • 1 hour keep warm cycle
  • 8 cycle settings

Loaf size and shape

The Oster 5838 58-Minute Expressbake Breadmaker produces horizontal loaves. The loaf size is 2 pounds, which is great. The loaf shape is similar, although not identical, to ordinary sandwich bread that you could find in your local grocery store. Of course, since it’s homemade, it tastes – and smells – much better!


11″  x 14″ x 11″ inches

Settings and cycles

This versatile and inexpensive bread maker comes with 8 pre-programmed cycles (basic, French, sweet, whole wheat, ExpressBake 58 minutes, ExpressBake 80 minutes, dough/pasta, and bake). Three crust colors – light, medium, and dark – are also available. When you consider that this bread machine commonly retails for $60 on Amazon.com, that’s quite a bargain.

Cycle length

  1. Basic
  2.  French
  3.  Sweet
  4.  Whole wheat
  5.  ExpressBake 58 minutes
  6.  ExpressBake 80 minutes
  7.  Dough/pasta
  8.  Bake

Additional features

Oster is a solid brand. Keeping in mind the needs of their customers, Oster provided this model with a few great extras. A one hour keep warm cycle is one of the best, allowing you to let fresh baked bread sit in the machine without becoming soggy or burning  after it finishes baking. Although there is no specific cycle for gluten free, many GF users report excellent results with this machine, too.

The compact size of this machine makes it an excellent pick for small spaces. Horizontal loaves are a big plus, too – they work better for sandwiches, and tend to resemble homemade bread more than their vertical counterparts.


Compact, cheap, and quick – this is the perfect bread machine for a family on the go. Pop your ingredients in, and let a fresh loaf of bread bake to accompany your meal. If you have guests coming over, and no time to prepare, fresh bread is still feasible. The variety of cycles ensures that you’ll be able to do more than just bake basic white and whole wheat breads, as well. Pasta doughs become a possibility, and you can even sneak out a sweet loaf for breakfasts if you feel like trying your hand at something new. Not bad for a low price point.


Unfortunately, there are a few wrinkles in the design of this machine. Despite Oster’s good reputation for making quality breadmakers, they failed to consider the possible need to include a second paddle in this machine. As a result, many users have complained about ingredients not mixing thoroughly, or loaves collapsing. You can avoid these problems by checking the dough before the first rise cycle begins, but that takes a little bit of the automated shine out of owning a bread machine. Additionally, Oster no longer allows the use of the timer for dough cycles on any of its machines, so donÕt try setting the timer to make a dough hours later.


In a perfect world, brands like Oster would always deliver a quality product. In this case, however, there are some problems you might want to consider before investing in the Oster 5838. The machine bakes great bread, when it works. Ingredients must be mixed extremely carefully, and you will need to check the loaf pan before the first rise cycle to ensure everything has mixed well.

Although it yields a horizontal loaf, the machine doesn’t always mix everything in correctly. The result can be collapsed loaves, or failed yeast. Some features which captivated fans of previous Oster bread machine models are not included in this design, such as the timer delay for the dough cycle.

The Oster 5838 58-minute Expressbake Bread Maker might seem like a good investment considering the numerous positive features, but you should think a bit before buying this machine. It’s priced well for beginning bakers, but the results you yield might not be worth the purchase.

My favorite machines remain the Zojirushis, but if you’re looking for a model under $100, check out my top choice here.

The manual for this breadmaker is available on Oster’s site:

Speak Your Mind